BDS Bullying tactics are hollow victory

It took less than 48 hours for the BDS to do a complete turn-around over Shashi Naidoo.  On Sunday, Ms Naidoo was the devil incarnate, the target of multiple death threats for having dared to tweet comments supportive of Israel.  Now, having apologised for her ‘heresy’, she is suddenly a celebrity. Indeed,  the intention now is to set her up as a poster girl for the BDS movement.   Shashi Naidoo, a local television personality, took to Social Media over the weekend to express the true facts about the Israel-Palestinian conflict. 

Naidoo published a written apology on Instagram, where the hate-fest continued, being labelled as an “Apartheid Sympathizer”.  Following which she shared a video apology to the Muslim community, stating that “The apology I made today was very sincere, I can assure you of that. I have already received 10 death threats today and a lot of backlash.” 

If all this represents a victory for BDS, and for anti-Israel extremists in general, it is a decidedly hollow one. Actually, what it represents is a triumph of censorship over freedom of expression, a victory for those who resort to threats, insults and intimidation to silence those who express views in support of Israel.  The tactics of the “Hate lobby” merely show how false is their claim to be motivated by human rights concerns.  Really, what motivates them is naked hatred for Israel and a desire to bully other South Africans into going along with their radical agenda. Shashi Naidoo is the latest victim of this bigoted vendetta. Unless ordinary South Africans take a stand and declare, “Enough!”, she will not be the last.

Ms Naidoo has expressed a willingness to learn more about the Middle East conflict.  We encourage her on this endeavour.  She certainly won’t learn anything but emotive rhetoric and half-truths from the BDS, and we hope that she won’t allow herself to be exploited by an obviously one sided agenda.

Issued by the SA Zionist Federation and SA Jewish Board of Deputies. 

Recent Articles

RACISM: DO THE DUCK TEST

Zev Krengel writes in the Sunday Independent.  His piece is a response to Zane Dangor who questioned whether Jewish leadership were using criticism of Israel to silence debate.  In this article Krengel applies the “Duck test” as an indication of antisemitism.

Yanir Grindler writes for the Daily Maverick "The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is complex enough without the shouting."

Equating Zionism with racism is far too easy a way out of proper debate around the roots of the conflict in the Middle East, and Israel Apartheid Week serves to exacerbate rather than defuse the tensions. The time has come for rational debate in an attempt to find common ground between the two opposing sides, rather than slogan-shouting.