Charisse Zeifert

Religious tolerance holds the key to fixing SA's ills



Pretoria News

Last Monday morning started on a high note.  If you were listening to SAfm’s with Sakina Kamwendo.

The discussion was “Religious Tolerance”, and the five speakers, each representing a different faith community, were in agreement: South Africans need to be more tolerant of each other, leadership needs to ensure that the various faiths work together in synergy, and education about one another is crucial.

The mullah expressed his appreciation that the respective faiths had reached out to the Muslim community to condemn the recent mosque desecrations in the Western Cape, including the depositing of a pig’s snout at one of them, while the rabbi was at pains to explain the benign nature of halaal and kosher signs on food products.

However, the goodwill expressed by the panellists was not present in many of the SMSes and comments made by the listeners.  These spoke to a different reality on the ground: anger; frustration and frequently out-and-out prejudice.

In this environment, scapegoating becomes inevitable, with minority groups invariably being singled out.

Add to this mix our current volatile political climate, and all too often Jews end up being the proverbial “football” to be kicked around for political gain.

Take, for example, an article published in City Press last week, discussing the political succession debate in the ANC.  It was reported that in certain quarters, Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa was being described as a liability to the party because he was “in the pockets of the Jews”.

Another recent example, also reported by the City Press, was in November last year, with Edward Zuma stating as fact the spurious claim that “mining licences are given to Jews”.

About the same time, following #FeesMustFall-related anti-Jewish graffiti appearing on the University of the Witwatersrand campus.  Twitter discussions around state capture resulted in accusations that “whites and Jews perfected state capture in 1900”.  

Former Western Cape ANC chairman Marius Fransman has been especially culpable of playing the Jewish financial conspiracy cared.  Speaking on Voice of the Cape on February 26, 2013, in what was self-evidently a ploy to elicit Muslim support for his party, he asserted that Western Cape Jewry was unfairly benefiting at the expense of the Muslims because of the policies of the DA (“We saw that the DA had given over building contracts in Woodstock and Observatory that historically were in the hands of Muslim and now they have given it to the people from the Jewish community”).

Later that year, he again singled out Jews as being especially guilty of benefiting at the expense of the majority population, stating that “98% of land and property owners actually is the white community and, in particular, people in the Jewish community”.

These and similar such incidents are part of a growing trend in which conspiracy theories alleging Jewish control of global finance and the singling out and scapegoating of Jews specifically for South Africa’s ill are becoming a common feature of political discourse.

Such notions are racist and factually baseless.  They constitute classic anti-Semitic modes of thinking that historically have been exploited the world over to both promote and justify discrimination, and sometimes even violent attacks, against Jewish communities.

The South African Jewish Board of Deputies has been actively and consistently calling for hate crimes legislation to be implemented in this country.

We work with other organisations, including the Hate Crimes Working Group, to educate against singling out for attack, any community because of its colour, faith, ethnicity, religion or sexual orientation.  And we do so because we know that hate crimes begin with hate speech.

In a society that struggles almost daily with incidences of racism, and where identity has long been used as a means of marginalising and repressing people, we urge all political parties and good citizens to eschew this kind of language and instil and practise the culture of tolerance and respect that our country so dearly needs.

Our religious leaders talking on SAfm were on the same page.  The challenge is to get all the good people of this country to follow, so that racist scapegoating and conspiracy theorising remains limited to the fringes of public discourse, where it belongs.

Recent Articles

Cosatu's Tony Ehrenreich Censured for Threatening Jewish Community

On 13 August 2014, then Western Cape Cosatu chairman Tony Ehrenreich posted a comment on Facebook calling for revenge attacks against the SA Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) and other “Zionist supporters” in retaliation for the deaths of Palestinian civilians. Amongst other inflammatory comments, he wrote, “The time has come to say very clearly that if a woman or child is killed in Gaza, then the Jewish board of deputies, who are complicit, will feel the wrath of the People of SA with the age old biblical teaching of an eye for an eye”.  

Charisse Zeifert writes for Saturday Citizen

Have you heard the joke where a Jew, an Afrikaner and an Indian walk into a Shebeen? It sounds like the kind of “witty” yarn that EFF leader Julius Malema would spin. Oh, wait, actually, he has already told tales about different minorities – singling them out for abuse. Most recently, he “cleverly” managed to insult two minority groups at the same time, when he said: “There’s a group of white right-wingers (read Afrikaners) who are being trained by Jews in Pretoria to be snipers.” (sic)

Jewish Affairs Rosh Hashanah 2018

We are pleased to announce that the Rosh Hashanah 2018 issue of Jewish Affairs has been posted on our website. The printed version will be sent to subscribers shortly. As always, we ask that you assist us in widening the reach of the journal by forwarding this message to anyone who may be interested.

In May this year, the State of Israel celebrated its 70th anniversary. To mark that memorable milestone, the Rosh Hashanah 2018 issue of Jewish Affairs is devoted almost entirely to the subject of Israel, and in particular to the noteworthy role that South African Jews played in its birth and early struggle for survival. The editorial board thanks all those who responded to its invitation to contribute their own memories and perspectives for this special JA issue.