Shaun Zagnoev

Ms Thokozile Xasa would like to give her support to the Palestinian people


Shaun Zagnoev writes for The Star:


Ms Thokozile Xasa would like to give her support to the Palestinian people (Star 27/03/18). The goal is a worthy one. However, one of the best ways of finding a solution to any given situation, is to first properly identify the problem. Notwithstanding her emotive ramble, and her evocation of a range of admirable people whom she quotes, the Israeli – Palestinian conflict cannot be resolved by sensationalising the issues. Nor can it be resolved by such overtly partisan interpretations of what it is all about.


Falsely accusing Israel of being an Apartheid State, a scurrilous propagandist tool, undermines the ANC ability to play a meaningful role in finding a solution to the conflict. To see the Palestinians as innocent victims with absolutely no control over their own destiny is not only patronising but further undermining our role in finding a solution.


Ms Xasa’s presentation of the situation is analogous to a doctor killing the patient to cure her of a toe injury (Israel, of course, being the patient, Ms Xasa being the doctor). It is a pity, because Sport, the ministry she heads, is a wonderful way of unifying people. Organisations within our own Jewish community, have previously held successful interactions between Israelis, Palestinians and South Africans on the soccer field. Israel has just held an international martial arts congress, bringing together practitioners from around the world all who put politics aside and engaged in the ancient art of respect. In spite of Ms Xasa’s protestation, Tennis SA recently a Davis Cup tie between South Africa and Israel in Irene. The players participated and the tennis community supported it, for the simple reason that sport brings people together.


Israel, like every other country, has its problems, and is naturally not blameless in the way it chooses to deal with them. That being said, to depict it as being worse than any other country (especially when considering the awful human rights violations taking place elsewhere in the region) suggesting that unreflecting prejudice rather than any considered analysis of the objective facts of the situation is behind it all. South Africa can and should play a meaningful role in helping the Palestinians to achieve statehood. Peace is indeed possible in the Middle East. But it needs to be negotiated by the opposing parties, the Israelis and Palestinians. This country focus should therefore be on encouraging both Israel and the Palestinian to come together in dialogue. What we need from our need from our Minister of Sport and Recreation is an urgent sense of fair play. If this was the case, the SAJBD would proudly support our government in its endeavours.


By Shaun Zagnoev
National Chairman
SA Jewish Board of Deputies


View the piece here: https://bit.ly/2q63SmR

Recent Articles

SAJBD pays tribute to Veronica Sobukwe

The South African Jewish Board of Deputies pays tribute to Zondeni Veronica Sobukwe, and extends its condolences to the Sobukwe family on her passing. Mrs Sobukwe will always have an honoured place in South African history for her loyal, steadfast support for her legendary husband, the great Pan-Africanist leader Robert Sobukwe, during the struggle against apartheid.

Our Madiba Moment of Reconciliation

On Mandela Day last week, sandwiches were made and handed out, blankets knitted and distributed and speeches given by impressive and inspiring world leaders. It is fitting then, that, on that auspicious day, I experienced what I believe was a profound ‘Mandela moment’, one that exemplified the Madiba values and spirit.

Women's Day 2018

As we prepare to celebrate Women’s Day tomorrow, the SAJBD urges all South Africans to do more to combat the scourge of violence against women in our society.  There is a critical need for greater awareness, education and the enforcement of the law around gender-based violence, as well as discrimination in the workplace and in other spheres of daily life.  Our young girls should also be empowered through education, skills and development.